Current Gaylord Weather

PhoneGuide

Directory

Browse Business Directory:

Classifieds

Search Gaylord Herald Times Classifieds:

Some fireworks illegal in Michigan could be legalized and sold to help raise money for state government. Do you think this is a good way for the state to raise revenue?
Yes
No
View Results

The Herald Times View: Otsego County fire board needs transparency
Friday, June 13, 2008 4:10 PM EDT
 
So for years the wrong process has been followed in choosing the Otsego County fire chief and now this year, with recommendations on how to do it, the results were contested.

That’s about right.

David Duffield has served on the department for decades, many of those as chief of the 40-member crew. He lost a narrow straw poll vote among volunteers which was then flipped by the board in the legally defined vote.

In the vote among those who will now serve under him against the vote by the board legally responsible for the department’s operation ... does it matter that in a hypothetically combined vote he won by 3?

It is almost inconsequential. The issue at hand is the transparency of the process and the best understanding that everyone can be given of how it is now supposed to work.
- Advertisement -
The Herald Times will continue to look into it.

At least in the meantime we have in Duffield someone we believe has proven himself over the years and is more than able to lead the department. Leadership through adversity is the toughest of all.
2 comment(s)

bjgaylord wrote on Jun 17, 2008 8:22 AM:

" I am surprised by the lack of concern or outrage from the Herald Times. As a newspaper with such a history for being the champion of "the Michigan Open Meetings Act" and public transparency, I would have expected a more vocal response from you. Perhaps that is what you meant by "the Herald Times will continue to look into it". But that is the weakest response to a violation of the open meetings act that I have ever heard from this paper. "

CUTTY wrote on Jun 14, 2008 4:40 AM:

" I dont believe it is fair to scew the vote by combining the votes of two seperate boards and thereby minimizing the results of the first vote which was not in favor of Mr. Duffield.
Also you last statement that leadership is tested in adversity kind of overtakes your previous statement that this paper would "look into" this situation doesnt it?
This sounds to me like the "good ole boy" network in full force in this county, with the predictably "in house" Herald Times rolling over for the local Rotary Club Et Al.
None of my comments is to indicate that the wrong choice was made. In the end, it perhaps was and is appropriate that Mr. Duffield was chosen.
The problem concerns the way this whole matter was handled.
Even though the right choice was perhaps made, doesnt obviate the fact that a certain clique of local residents, Mary Sanders among them, are highly dominant of local politics in this community.
Its time that a new elite took over. "

If you have registered, enter your Member ID/Password to comment.
*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?
 
You must agree to the Terms of Use and register
with a valid email address to post comments.